20 Dec McGill Big 3: Why it doesn’t work for you
Mcgill Big 3: Why it doesn’t work for you
The McGill big 3 doesn’t work! I see it every day. “McGill’s big three doesn’t work for me; it worsened my symptoms! It does nothing; it makes my back hurt! Or, they are too easy and didn’t do anything. In this article, I’m going to discuss why the Big 3 doesn’t work for you and there are three primary reasons I see in my work with clients and back pain. 1. Improper form and technique, 2. you haven’t removed the causes of your pain, 3—inappropriate application.
Improper execution and form are likely the culprits for those who ‘aren’t getting anything out of the big 3.’ I see it all the time; even when people claim to be coaches and masters of the movement themselves, they are highly bastardized. As I explain in the video, they aren’t held for the appropriate amount of time (up to 10sec), and sometimes are done so poorly that they are winding up one’s back pain. For example, one standard technique error for the Birddog is the leg being too high in the air, causing movement in the lower back instead of hip extension, which is meant to help lock in and stiffen the core. Fortunately, the side plank is pretty easy to execute, but the curl-up, not as fortunate, is by far the most bastardized. I have included a good technique video for you to refer to in this article.
Haven’t removed the cause
Another common mistake people make when criticizing the big 3 is that their pain isn’t improving, and they expect the big 3 to take away all their pain magically. Now, in some cases, stabilizing the core and giving the spine some bolstering support can take away the pain. But for those more deeply pained, a more robust and thorough approach will be needed, i.e., an assessment (comprehensive) and removing the causes of pain. This could be a posture, a movement, an exercise, or a position that keeps them pained. It could be as simple as lying in bed for too many hours a night or the way they wash the dishes and take out the trash repeatedly. In my experience, to beat back pain, you must remove the cause. This is a foundational pillar that I learned personally from Dr. McGill. This was the biggest game-changer in my back pain story. I was constantly brutalizing my back with poor posture and spine hygiene.
Improper application is a common enemy for those who want to regain their robustness for life. They haphazardly apply the big 3 when it’s convenient or when they feel like it until they start feeling better, then return to the old program that injured them. The improper application could be too much of the big 3, too little, or even using them when they are inappropriate. Every back injury is unique – some people are in such great pained states that anything winds up their pain. In Back Mechanic, we suggest those in severe pain rest and consider doing virtual surgery. In short, virtual surgery is taking a reprieve and pretending as though they had surgery on their back and treating their day as such; resting and recovering.
Final thoughts about the McGill big three and their effectiveness
There are many reasons why people don’t recover from their back injuries. And this is not my purpose for this article. My intent for this article is to shed some light on why the big 3 gets a bad reputation at times and also clarify why I see many people struggle. Once they read in context in Gift of Injury or Ultimate Back – readers tend to understand the big three and how to correctly apply them in their pain-free pursuits. The problem comes when someone takes an exercise they don’t understand or really know and just blindly uses them. The blind leading the blind is a great way to describe some of the dissents you read about from so-called back pain experts.
Latest posts by Brian Carroll (see all)
- Trip to DOPE and Matt Vincent’s Podcast in St Louis - November 28, 2023
- Trip to St Louis for a colab with Squat University - November 21, 2023
- Getting To Know The Backfitpro Team: Stuart McGill x Brian Carroll - November 3, 2023