Article Rundown

• Pros and cons of cold plunges
• Cold plunge for back pain
• Contrast therapy
• What is the best for YOU?

Cold Plunges, Ice Baths, and Back Pain: A Balanced Perspective on Recovery Therapy

In this video, I will discuss the popular topic of cold plunges and ice baths, sharing my perspective on their effectiveness for recovery, especially in relation to back pain. Cold plunges have surged in popularity, becoming a hot topic on the internet. I aim to provide a clear analysis of whether this therapy is beneficial for you or whether it’s something you may want to avoid. Additionally, I will touch on contrast therapy—alternating between hot and cold—and explore whether this method could be a better option for your recovery.

Cold Plunges for Recovery: The Pros and Cons

When it comes to recovery, cold plunges or ice baths may be beneficial for some individuals, particularly those who enjoy the cold and feel rejuvenated afterward. For others, it can serve as a mental challenge, offering a sense of accomplishment and resilience. However, when considering the physical benefits, the evidence supporting cold therapy is less clear. While proponents often claim that cold plunges can significantly boost testosterone levels or enhance recovery, I haven’t seen substantial proof that it delivers such dramatic results. The truth is, while cold exposure might offer temporary relief or a mental boost, the long-term benefits for physical recovery are more debatable.

Cold Plunges and Back Pain: A Misleading Solution

When it comes to back pain, specifically in my experience with discogenic back pain, I believe cold therapy, including ice baths and cold plunges, may not be the most effective solution. Recent research suggests that while ice can numb pain—similar to the effects of NSAIDs like ibuprofen—it can also hinder the healing process. This is because ice can block the body’s anti-inflammatory signals, which are essential for promoting healing. Although cold therapy may alleviate inflammation and provide temporary pain relief, it may not be addressing the root cause of the problem.

Cold plunges can exacerbate discogenic back pain. The sitting position required for a cold plunge can place additional strain on your back, which can lead to muscle spasms for those with existing back issues. For instance, if sitting causes you pain (discogenic pain can do this), I would avoid trying to plunge your way out of back pain.

The cold can also cause muscles to constrict, leading to stiffness and discomfort when you exit the plunge. For some individuals, even the awkward act of getting in or out of a cold plunge can trigger spasms. Therefore, depending on the tissues affected, I do not recommend cold plunges or ice baths for individuals suffering from back pain. While the temporary release of endorphins might make you feel better in the moment, it is unlikely to provide long-term relief—and could potentially delay healing.

This is similar to the concept of the stretch reflex, where people may stretch to alleviate back pain, only to experience a temporary sense of relief followed by muscle tightness and discomfort when the stretch reflex kicks in. Just because something provides temporary relief does not mean it is a sustainable or practical solution for your pain in the long term.

Contrast Therapy: A Better Alternative for Recovery

For athletes looking for effective recovery methods—excluding those with back pain—I suggest exploring contrast therapy. This involves alternating between heat and cold in cycles, which I have found to be more beneficial for both short-term and long-term recovery. Contrast therapy can promote better circulation, reduce muscle soreness, and improve overall recovery. It is particularly useful for athletes, including fighters, as it not only enhances physical recovery but also builds mental toughness.

Contrast therapy offers a more balanced approach compared to cold plunges or ice baths alone. It encourages both relaxation and stimulation, providing benefits without the potential drawbacks of prolonged cold exposure. However, as with all recovery methods, it’s important to note that each case should be considered individually. Some people may still find cold therapy beneficial, while others may not tolerate it well.

I’ve had several clients with back issues who tried cold plunges for pain relief, only to experience worsening symptoms afterward. In one case, a client ended up in the emergency room due to a severe discogenic back spasm triggered by the cold plunge. This experience not only set back their recovery by months but it also reinforced the need to be cautious with cold therapy, especially for individuals with pre-existing conditions like back pain. Again, for some back pain, it might help, but we must pose the question, “what kind of back pain are we dealing with?” 

Conclusion: The Importance of a Holistic Approach

If you are considering cold therapy, I would recommend opting for contrast therapy—alternating between hot and cold—instead of relying solely on cold plunges or ice baths. However, it’s important to recognize that no recovery method is a “magic bullet.” Cold therapy, while it may offer some benefits, should be part of a holistic approach to recovery that includes proper nutrition, sufficient sleep, appropriate training, and adequate rest. Without these foundational elements in place, cold therapy alone is unlikely to provide meaningful, lasting benefits.

Ultimately, recovery is a personalized process. What works for one person may not work for another. If you suffer from back pain, it is essential to explore a variety of approaches and consult with a professional who can guide you toward the best solution for your specific needs. By taking a thoughtful, individualized approach to recovery, you can optimize your results and work toward long-term health and well-being.

BRIAN DOES ONLINE AND IN-PERSON COACHING!

Back Injured Average Mary or Joe who wants their life back

Back Injured Athlete Wanting to Return to Sport

Lift and exercise coaching & cueing to troubleshoot form

Program adherence & accountability coaching