Article Rundown

• Comparing WebMD vs Dr. McGill’s methods
• Common questions on back pain
• More in-depth answers than WebMD
• Holistic approach to beat back pain the right way

Debunking Common Back Pain Myths: A Comparison of WebMD and Dr. Stuart McGill’s Approach

In this video, I address the top seven most-searched questions on back pain from WebMD and compare their answers with the insights of Dr. Stuart McGill, a leading expert in spine biomechanics. WebMD’s general recommendations often fall short when it comes to truly understanding and managing back pain. Instead, I’ll reference Dr. McGill’s book, Back Mechanic, to provide evidence-based strategies for assessment and treatment.

1. What Is Causing My Back Pain?

Determining the root cause of back pain without a thorough assessment is nearly impossible. A quick 15-minute consultation with a healthcare provider is not sufficient to diagnose the issue accurately. A proper assessment, as emphasized by Dr. McGill, can take three to four hours to truly identify the pain mechanism(s). Without this step, any treatment approach is essentially guesswork, which can do more harm than good.

2. Can Serious Conditions Be Causing My Back Pain?

WebMD suggests that serious conditions could be the underlying cause of back pain, which is true in some cases. However, to rule out serious conditions such as cancer or cysts, you must consult your primary physician and undergo MRI imaging. Before starting any rehabilitation program with me, I always recommend eliminating these possibilities first. Once serious medical conditions are ruled out, we can focus on the specific mechanics of your pain and develop a personalized recovery plan.

3. What Will Worsen My Back Pain, and How Can I Prevent It?

Back pain triggers vary significantly from person to person, making a thorough assessment crucial. Some individuals experience pain when extending their spine due to disc height loss, while others may suffer from pain induced by flexion. Pain patterns also evolve over time as the condition progresses. Without understanding which movements or postures exacerbate or alleviate your pain, attempting to address it with generic recommendations is ineffective. This is why an individualized assessment is key.

4. Can Stress Contribute to Back Pain?

Stress can amplify existing back pain but is not typically the root cause. While emotional and psychological stress can heighten pain perception, there is most likely an underlying mechanical or physical issue for back pain to develop. When assessing a patient, we consider their job, daily routine, and personal life to determine how these factors may be influencing their condition. Addressing stress is important, but it must be paired with proper movement and rehabilitation strategies.

5. What Are My Treatment Options?

Treatment options depend entirely on the cause of the pain and the individual’s specific condition. Dr. McGill outlines in Back Mechanic who might be a candidate for surgery and the red flags to watch for. Generally, I recommend starting with the most conservative treatment approach, progressing to medical interventions if necessary, and considering surgery only as a last resort.

Dr. McGill also introduces the concept of “virtual surgery,” where a person behaves as if they’ve undergone surgery—reducing movement, allowing tissues to heal, and gradually rebuilding their strength. For many individuals, this approach alone is enough to significantly reduce pain and restore function. Generic rehabilitation plans often fail because they do not account for the nuances of each person’s injury.

6. What Can I Do at Home to Reduce My Back Pain?

Yes, there are several ways to manage back pain at home, but they must be tailored to the individual’s condition. Dr. McGill provides detailed guidelines in Back Mechanic on pain management techniques, such as:

• Learning to move in ways that avoid pain triggers.
• Utilizing proper hip mechanics instead of the lower back when lifting objects.
• Incorporating pain-free exercises to gradually increase load tolerance and build resilience.

7. Should I Get Surgery? What Are the Risks and Benefits?

Surgical intervention for back pain is a complex decision. Some surgeons claim high success rates, but the definition of “success” can be misleading. Dr. McGill warns that success in medical terms may only mean the patient survived the procedure or experienced temporary relief.

It is crucial to ask surgeons detailed questions about long-term outcomes. How long does the relief last? What is the risk of recurrence? What are the potential complications? In fact, 95% of people we see who are told they need surgery ultimately recover without it. This underscores the importance of consulting the right professionals and exploring all conservative options first.

Conclusion

Back pain is a highly individualized condition that requires precise assessment and a customized approach to treatment. While WebMD provides broad and often vague recommendations, Dr. McGill’s research-based strategies offer a more reliable path to recovery. By identifying the true cause of pain and using targeted rehabilitation techniques, many individuals can avoid unnecessary surgeries and reclaim a pain-free life. If you’re struggling with back pain, take the time to undergo a thorough assessment and make informed decisions about your treatment options.

BRIAN DOES ONLINE AND IN-PERSON COACHING!

Back Injured Average Mary or Joe who wants their life back

Back Injured Athlete Wanting to Return to Sport

Lift and exercise coaching & cueing to troubleshoot form

Program adherence & accountability coaching